I believe action which you feel according to scripture is right for you
..........
BNN said:
..........
I believe action which you feel according to scripture is right for you but wrong for others. For others that action is right which they feel according to scripture. For fish swimming is right but flying is wrong. Flying is right for bird.
..........
ANN said:
..........
Your perspective highlights a powerful principle of contextual duty and inherent nature. By using the metaphor of the fish and the bird, you are pointing to a concept deeply embedded in many philosophical and scriptural traditions: that righteousness, purpose, and proper action are deeply intertwined with an individual's unique nature and framework.
Here is an exploration of how this concept manifests through that lens:
1. The Principle of Inherent Nature (Swabhava)
Just as a fish is naturally equipped for water and a bird for the sky, different beings possess distinct intrinsic qualities. From this viewpoint, what is natural and life-sustaining for one entity would be unnatural and destructive for another.
For the Fish: Swimming aligns with its physical form, survival, and environment. Attempting to fly would go against its very nature and lead to failure.
For the Bird: Flying utilizes its wings and fulfills its biological destiny. Grounding itself entirely in water would suppress its innate capabilities.
2. Alignment with Scriptural Guidance
Scriptures in various traditions often speak to the idea of individual paths tailored to different stages of life, temperaments, or spiritual capacities.
Personal Alignment: The core idea is that a person finds harmony by following the path prescribed for their specific role or nature (often referred to in classical texts as dharmic duty).
Avoiding Universal Prescriptions: What is a righteous duty for one person—given their specific station, responsibilities, or inner makeup—might be entirely inappropriate for someone else whose life path requires a different focus.
3. Harmony Through Diversity
When everyone adheres to the path true to their own nature and scriptural guidance, society and nature function in balance. Chaos arises primarily when individuals abandon their rightful duties to imitate paths meant for others, much like a fish trying to fly or a bird trying to swim. True wisdom lies in recognizing one's own unique function and honoring the different, yet equally valid, paths of others.
BNN said:
..........
I believe action which you feel according to scripture is right for you but wrong for others. For others that action is right which they feel according to scripture. For fish swimming is right but flying is wrong. Flying is right for bird.
..........
ANN said:
..........
Your perspective highlights a powerful principle of contextual duty and inherent nature. By using the metaphor of the fish and the bird, you are pointing to a concept deeply embedded in many philosophical and scriptural traditions: that righteousness, purpose, and proper action are deeply intertwined with an individual's unique nature and framework.
Here is an exploration of how this concept manifests through that lens:
1. The Principle of Inherent Nature (Swabhava)
Just as a fish is naturally equipped for water and a bird for the sky, different beings possess distinct intrinsic qualities. From this viewpoint, what is natural and life-sustaining for one entity would be unnatural and destructive for another.
For the Fish: Swimming aligns with its physical form, survival, and environment. Attempting to fly would go against its very nature and lead to failure.
For the Bird: Flying utilizes its wings and fulfills its biological destiny. Grounding itself entirely in water would suppress its innate capabilities.
2. Alignment with Scriptural Guidance
Scriptures in various traditions often speak to the idea of individual paths tailored to different stages of life, temperaments, or spiritual capacities.
Personal Alignment: The core idea is that a person finds harmony by following the path prescribed for their specific role or nature (often referred to in classical texts as dharmic duty).
Avoiding Universal Prescriptions: What is a righteous duty for one person—given their specific station, responsibilities, or inner makeup—might be entirely inappropriate for someone else whose life path requires a different focus.
3. Harmony Through Diversity
When everyone adheres to the path true to their own nature and scriptural guidance, society and nature function in balance. Chaos arises primarily when individuals abandon their rightful duties to imitate paths meant for others, much like a fish trying to fly or a bird trying to swim. True wisdom lies in recognizing one's own unique function and honoring the different, yet equally valid, paths of others.